When it comes to baking, the choice between vanilla bean paste vs. vanilla extract can significantly affect the flavour and texture of your desserts. Both have their unique qualities Understanding when to use each can help elevate your culinary creations.
Vanilla paste is a thick, syrup-like substance that contains actual vanilla bean seeds. This gives the paste a more intense flavour and a visual appeal, with specks of vanilla throughout your dish.
It’s perfect for recipes where the look and flavour of real vanilla beans are desired, such as custards, ice creams, and crème brûlée. The paste also offers convenience since it provides the rich taste of whole vanilla beans without splitting and scraping them.
Halal vanilla extract is a liquid obtained by soaking vanilla beans in a non-alcoholic solvent. It offers a smooth, versatile flavour that easily blends into various baked goods, making it a staple in most kitchens. If you’re following dietary restrictions or prefer a non-alcoholic option, the halal vanilla extract provides the same great flavour without compromising quality or religious beliefs.
So, which one should you use? If you’re looking for a robust and authentic vanilla taste with visible vanilla bean specks, vanilla paste is the way to go. However, halal vanilla extract is your best bet if you need a versatile ingredient that can easily be mixed into any recipe.
Did you know that you can actually substitute vanilla bean paste for vanilla extract in recipes? Still, it’s important to note the flavor and texture differences. Vanilla bean paste contains actual vanilla seeds, which add a richer flavor and visual appeal to your dish.
Extract, on the other hand, is liquid and lacks the speckled look of vanilla seeds. Use them interchangeably, remembering that paste delivers a more potent vanilla punch.
The conversion is simple: one teaspoon of vanilla bean paste vs vanilla extract equals one teaspoon of vanilla extract. However, vanilla bean paste’s concentrated flavor may make it preferable for recipes where a robust vanilla profile is desired.
Vanilla bean paste is often considered better because it combines the potency of vanilla extract with the authentic flavor of vanilla seeds. This makes it ideal for desserts where the appearance and taste of real vanilla beans are key, such as custards, ice creams, and frostings.
Absolutely! Vanilla beans are a fantastic substitute for vanilla bean paste vs vanilla extract, offering a pure and natural flavor. Use one vanilla bean to replace one teaspoon of extract for an authentic vanilla experience.

Recipes That Use Vanilla Bean Paste
What is vanilla bean paste used for? It’s perfect for recipes that benefit from its rich flavor and
visual appeal, such as:
- Custards and Puddings – Adds depth and visible vanilla specks.
- Ice Cream and Gelato – Enhances creamy desserts with a gourmet touch.
- Cakes and Cookies – Provides a stronger vanilla taste than extract.
- Beverages – Ideal for lattes, milkshakes, and smoothies.
Recipes That Use Vanilla Extract
When comparing vanilla bean paste vs vanilla extract, vanilla extract works best in recipes where
the flavor blends smoothly:
- Custards and Puddings – Adds depth and visible vanilla specks.
- Ice Cream and Gelato – Enhances creamy desserts with a gourmet touch.
- Cakes and Cookies – Provides a stronger vanilla taste than extract.
- Beverages – Ideal for lattes, milkshakes, and smoothies.

Pros and Cons: Vanilla Bean Paste vs Vanilla Extract
When deciding between vanilla bean paste vs vanilla extract, there are key factors to consider. In terms of flavor, vanilla bean paste has a richer, more intense taste, while the vanilla extract is milder and smoother. The paste also includes visible vanilla specks, adding a gourmet touch to desserts, whereas the extract is purely liquid with no visual elements.
Vanilla bean paste is best for high-end baking and gourmet recipes, while vanilla extract is more versatile for everyday cooking. Price-wise, vanilla bean paste is more expensive, but it offers a more luxurious flavor profile. However, vanilla extract is more affordable and widely available. In terms of convenience, vanilla bean paste eliminates the need for scraping beans, while vanilla extract is easy to measure and mix into recipes.
Need a substitute vanilla bean paste? Try combining vanilla extract with scraped vanilla beans for a similar effect!